{
  "attribution": "Schmieder, Pannusch, Vannieuwenhuyse, Briesen, Minceva (2023), 'Influence of flow rate, particle size, and temperature on espresso extraction kinetics', Foods 12, 2871, DOI 10.3390/foods12152871, open access CC-BY. DERIVED replicate-level extraction-yield values and RSM predictions are published with attribution; no raw source CSV is redistributed.",
  "badge": "OBSERVED",
  "caveat": "A dial number is NOT a particle size and is non-portable without a calibrated adapter; do not read a universal 'too-fine optimum'. Self-correction here downgrades ONE result — it does not prove every current result is correct. Static channeling remains a viable GENERATOR (model capacity); the data just do not identify it. The 1.4-vs-1.7 interval includes zero, so means are 'ordered', not 'statistically monotone'. No confidence claim beyond the reported Welch interval.",
  "compares_grinder_dials": true,
  "dataset_manifest_ids": [
    "schmieder2023/cup_masses",
    "schmieder2023/rsm_coefficients"
  ],
  "evidence_partitions": [
    {
      "badge": "OBSERVED",
      "partition": "corrected_replicate_data",
      "role": "observed",
      "scope": "One machine, one coffee, one campaign, and one fixed nominal central condition; the within-cell spread is run-to-run variance at a fixed NOMINAL dial (the experimental unit), with no replication across machines/coffees/campaigns. A grinder dial is not a particle size and is non-portable to another grinder without a calibrated adapter.",
      "strength": "independent"
    },
    {
      "badge": "RECONSTRUCTED",
      "partition": "rounded_coefficient_and_refit_audit",
      "role": "derived",
      "scope": "A computational audit: the literal rounded-coefficient central value vs a least-squares refit vs the observed central mean. Verification against the committed data, NOT independent experimental validation.",
      "strength": "verification"
    },
    {
      "badge": "EXPLORATORY_SIMULATION",
      "partition": "model_interior_feature",
      "role": "simulated",
      "scope": "Model capacity to draw an interior feature at two pressures, compared with the descriptive replicate spread. This is capacity, NOT identification of channeling as the cause; 0.218 EY-points is a descriptive reference, not a formal minimum-detectable-effect or noise floor.",
      "strength": "qualitative"
    },
    {
      "badge": null,
      "partition": "superseded_headline",
      "role": "superseded",
      "scope": "The interior 'fine-grind maximum' headline read from the literal rounded-coefficient central value and the mixed-unit target. Retained visibly as a revised record; it carries NO current evidence badge.",
      "status": "superseded/revised"
    }
  ],
  "evidence_strength": "independent",
  "fidelity_ceiling": "Per-partition, NOT one global class: the corrected replicate correction is OBSERVED / independent; the rounded-coefficient/refit audit is RECONSTRUCTED / verification (a computational audit, not independent experimental validation); the model interior feature is EXPLORATORY_SIMULATION / qualitative and is model capacity, never mechanism identification; the superseded interior-maximum headline carries no current evidence badge.",
  "generator": "puckworks.public.analysis_autopsy.build_payload",
  "producer": "puckworks.harness.result1_magnitude_comparison",
  "redistribution_class": "CC-BY DERIVED replicate-level extraction-yield values and RSM predictions, attributed; no raw Schmieder source CSV is redistributed",
  "revision_record": [
    "Superseded internal headline: an interior 'fine-grind' extraction-yield maximum, read from a literal evaluation of the rounded published RSM coefficients at the central condition (~6.723 g, treated as if it were the real absolute level) and a target that mixed mg solute masses with g TDS.",
    "Problem 1 — unit/aggregation: mg-scale solute masses and g-scale TDS/cup-mass quantities were aggregated before conversion to one coherent observable; the target must first be rebuilt as a single-basis TDS-derived extraction yield.",
    "Problem 2 — printed precision: limited printed coefficient precision makes the literal absolute reconstruction unreliable; the project's least-squares refit central-condition prediction (~3.918 g) is near the observed central mean (~3.876 g). The 6.723 g figure is a literal evaluation of rounded coefficients, NOT itself a coefficient and NOT a real 1.7x over-prediction.",
    "Correction — coherent target: extraction yield rebuilt from TDS on one consistent basis, so the three dial cells can be compared as one observable.",
    "Corrected replicate-level finding: the raw cell means are ordered across dial with the middle below the coarse one (18.27 -> 19.38 -> 19.62 % EY); the Welch 95% interval on the middle-minus-coarse (dial 1.7 - dial 2.0) contrast excludes zero -> no observed interior maximum in these cells.",
    "Remaining model-capacity statement: a channeling model can still GENERATE a small interior feature, but the tested feature is smaller than the descriptive within-cell replicate spread -- model capacity, not identification of channeling as the cause.",
    "Resulting downgrade: the interior 'fine-grind maximum' interpretation is superseded and revised down to a model-capacity statement; self-correction here downgrades ONE result and does not prove every current result is correct."
  ],
  "schema_version": 2,
  "scope": "Schmieder E65S grinder DoE at one fixed central flow/temperature condition; TDS-derived EY observable; grinder-dial positions (not particle sizes).",
  "series": [
    {
      "badge": "OBSERVED",
      "categories": [
        "dial 1.4 (finer)",
        "dial 1.7 (middle)",
        "dial 2.0 (coarser)"
      ],
      "caveat": "grinder-DIAL positions, non-portable to another grinder without a calibrated adapter; the cell means are ordered with the middle below the coarse cell, so there is no observed interior maximum here (the 1.4-vs-1.7 interval includes zero, so the means are ORDERED, not statistically monotone)",
      "cell_stds": [
        0.451,
        0.145,
        0.058
      ],
      "component": "schmieder2023 replicate cup masses -> TDS-derived EY",
      "label": "Observed extraction yield by grinder dial (replicate points)",
      "method": "individual measured replicate yields per dial cell; the overlays are each cell's mean and each cell's OWN within-cell standard deviation (uncorrected, ddof=0 — a descriptive reference, not a Bessel-corrected estimator), with n per cell (3/6/3)",
      "ns": [
        3,
        6,
        3
      ],
      "replicates": [
        [
          17.743,
          18.215,
          18.843
        ],
        [
          19.48,
          19.439,
          19.562,
          19.284,
          19.404,
          19.117
        ],
        [
          19.675,
          19.649,
          19.542
        ]
      ],
      "role": "observed",
      "scope": "one machine, one coffee, one campaign, one fixed nominal central condition; grinder-DIAL positions, non-portable without a calibrated adapter",
      "strength": "independent",
      "unit": "% EY",
      "values": [
        18.27,
        19.38,
        19.62
      ]
    },
    {
      "badge": "RECONSTRUCTED",
      "categories": [
        "rounded published coefficients",
        "project refit",
        "observed central mean"
      ],
      "caveat": "limited printed coefficient precision prevents reconstructing the absolute level from the printed values; the refit is near the observed mean. The 6.723 g figure is a literal evaluation of rounded coefficients, not itself a coefficient",
      "component": "schmieder RSM Eq.4 evaluated/refit at the central condition",
      "label": "Central-condition cup-mass value: rounded published coefficients vs project refit vs observed mean",
      "method": "central-condition cup-mass prediction three ways: a literal evaluation of the rounded published coefficients (~6.723 g), the project's least-squares refit to the committed cup masses (~3.918 g), and the observed central-condition mean (~3.876 g)",
      "role": "derived",
      "scope": "a computational audit against the committed data — verification, not independent experimental validation",
      "strength": "verification",
      "unit": "g",
      "values": [
        6.723,
        3.918,
        3.876
      ]
    },
    {
      "badge": "EXPLORATORY_SIMULATION",
      "categories": [
        "model interior prominence (5 bar)",
        "model interior prominence (9 bar)",
        "mean within-cell SD (descriptive, ddof=0)"
      ],
      "caveat": "the model CAN draw an interior feature (capacity); the tested feature is smaller than the descriptive replicate spread, so the data do not identify it, and this is not identification of channeling as the cause. The 0.218 EY-point spread is a descriptive reference, not a formal minimum-detectable-effect or noise floor",
      "component": "channeling interior-max sensitivity vs the descriptive replicate spread",
      "label": "Model interior prominence vs descriptive replicate spread",
      "method": "model interior prominence at two pressures compared with the mean within-cell sample SD across the three dial cells",
      "role": "simulated",
      "scope": "model-capacity context on the tested closure grid; not a mechanism-identification claim",
      "strength": "qualitative",
      "unit": "EY-points",
      "values": [
        0.154,
        0.0,
        0.218
      ]
    }
  ],
  "source_commit": "d4e131fa064c3394ac1dc32aaa55e6c483e14e14",
  "source_data_sha256": {
    "cup_masses.csv": "39b7c16f9d9da614f151f46cb0db1440d43f150fbf49d3d2119f3f2fa1622f43",
    "rsm_coefficients.csv": "9de2503130ad6689f6f0ad08ef0c781b2bcc099687b5db31443edb0a60d08adc"
  },
  "source_ids": {
    "schmieder_doe": "Foods 12, 2871 (DOI 10.3390/foods12152871, CC-BY)"
  },
  "story_id": "PV-04",
  "title": "How We Falsified Our Own Espresso Headline",
  "units": {
    "ey_dial_1p4_pct": "% EY",
    "ey_dial_1p7_pct": "% EY",
    "ey_dial_2p0_pct": "% EY",
    "mean_within_cell_std_EYpt": "EY-points",
    "mid_vs_coarse_contrast_EYpt": "EY-points",
    "model_bump_lt_within_cell_var": "boolean",
    "model_prominence_5bar_EYpt": "EY-points",
    "model_prominence_9bar_EYpt": "EY-points",
    "rsm_printed_central_g": "g",
    "rsm_printed_is_rounding_artifact": "boolean",
    "rsm_raw_central_g": "g",
    "rsm_refit_central_g": "g",
    "welch_ci95_hi_EYpt": "EY-points",
    "welch_ci95_lo_EYpt": "EY-points",
    "within_cell_std_EYpt": "EY-points"
  },
  "values": {
    "ey_dial_1p4_pct": 18.27,
    "ey_dial_1p7_pct": 19.38,
    "ey_dial_2p0_pct": 19.62,
    "mean_within_cell_std_EYpt": 0.218,
    "mid_vs_coarse_contrast_EYpt": -0.241,
    "model_bump_lt_within_cell_var": true,
    "model_prominence_5bar_EYpt": 0.154,
    "model_prominence_9bar_EYpt": 0.0,
    "rsm_printed_central_g": 6.723,
    "rsm_printed_is_rounding_artifact": true,
    "rsm_raw_central_g": 3.876,
    "rsm_refit_central_g": 3.918,
    "welch_ci95_hi_EYpt": -0.06,
    "welch_ci95_lo_EYpt": -0.422,
    "within_cell_std_EYpt": 0.218
  }
}
