{
  "attribution": "Observed 9-bar flow trace: Waszkiewicz, Myck, Białas, Puciata-Mroczyńska, Dzikowski, Szymczak, Lisicki (2025), 'Under pressure: poroelastic regulation of flow in espresso brewing', Zenodo record 18046315, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.18046315 (arXiv:2512.21528), CC-BY-4.0. Swelling branch parameters: mo2023_2 (Elsevier, paywalled) — only derived model output is shown, no source table is redistributed.",
  "badge": "EXPLORATORY_SIMULATION",
  "caveat": "This rejects THIS composition, not swelling in general and not a universal rule that added physics reduces accuracy. It does NOT prove the extraction-only mechanism is correct or uniquely identified. The composition is not coupled into the Guided Espresso Pull. Components are fitted/calibrated; a lower residual is verification against one trace, not independent validation.",
  "composition_checklist": [
    "Does each component use the same state definition?",
    "Does the state share one reference volume and the same bounds?",
    "Are the time origins and the pressure/flow nodes compatible?",
    "Does a fitted parameter in one component already absorb what the other adds?",
    "Are mass and energy balances preserved across the composition?",
    "Do both components operate in overlapping evidence domains?",
    "Is the combined observation operator still physically meaningful?",
    "Does the composite beat a simple null benchmark?"
  ],
  "dataset_manifest_ids": [
    "waszkiewicz2025/traces_time_dependent",
    "waszkiewicz2025/constants"
  ],
  "evidence_strength": "qualitative",
  "fidelity_ceiling": "coupled kappa(t) FRAMEWORK; branch fidelity inherited from donors (mo2023_2 swelling is fixed-dP and unvalidated on a saturated rig). Exploratory model-composition evidence, never a validated composition.",
  "generator": "puckworks.public.model_composition.build_payload",
  "model_params": {
    "eps0_reference_porosity": 0.17,
    "eps_clamp_max": 0.95,
    "eps_clamp_min": 0.02,
    "eval_window_s": [
      15.0,
      95.0
    ],
    "flow_unit": "g/s",
    "pressure_bar": 9.0,
    "state_variable": "shared porosity eps (dimensionless)",
    "swelling_powder_class": "M",
    "time_unit": "s"
  },
  "models": {
    "brewer2026.coupled_kappa_t": "shared-porosity synthesis (framework fidelity = shakiest branch)",
    "mo2023_2.swelling": "fixed-dP swelling branch (imported pre-fitted parameters)",
    "waszkiewicz2025.poroelastic": "poroelastic flow closure (drives the extraction-only branch)"
  },
  "producers": [
    "puckworks.harness.kappa_t_ladder",
    "puckworks.models.brewer2026.coupled_kappa_t.degeneracy_rmse",
    "puckworks.models.brewer2026.coupled_kappa_t.composition_residual",
    "puckworks.models.brewer2026.coupled_kappa_t.simulate"
  ],
  "redistribution_class": "observed trace CC-BY-4.0 (redistributable, attributed, downsampled); model traces puckworks-derived; no paywalled source table redistributed",
  "schema_version": 1,
  "scope": "One dataset/campaign (waszkiewicz2025 9-bar trace), one observation operator, one tested shared-porosity composition, one shared-state definition; the swelling parameters are mo2023_2's, applied to a saturated pre-wet rig.",
  "series": [
    {
      "caveat": "one rig, one coffee, one pressure; redistributed under CC-BY-4.0 with attribution",
      "component": "waszkiewicz2025 rig measurement",
      "label": "Observed flow (9 bar)",
      "method": "measured Q(t), downsampled from the CC-BY Zenodo trace",
      "role": "observed",
      "unit": "g/s",
      "values": [
        0.00121,
        0.00714,
        -0.00055,
        -0.00278,
        0.00403,
        0.01446,
        0.00254,
        0.0166,
        0.05522,
        0.11871,
        0.16847,
        0.24222,
        0.30417,
        0.36435,
        0.42111,
        0.52045,
        0.63201,
        0.74917,
        0.82854,
        0.95638,
        1.10463,
        1.25937,
        1.40093,
        1.53989,
        1.62851,
        1.73016,
        1.78451,
        1.85178,
        1.91758,
        1.95776,
        1.97654,
        1.9734,
        2.00204,
        2.00954,
        1.98376,
        2.00536,
        2.00627,
        1.96746,
        1.95139,
        1.94958,
        1.94991,
        1.92491,
        1.93366,
        1.92821,
        1.9215,
        1.93972,
        1.93115,
        1.91227,
        1.89948,
        1.88834,
        1.89228,
        1.90154,
        1.87727,
        1.8715,
        1.882,
        1.86593,
        1.86176,
        1.86944,
        1.86379,
        1.87648,
        1.86898,
        1.86391,
        1.8658,
        1.82492
      ]
    },
    {
      "caveat": "a lower residual is not proof the mechanism is uniquely identified or correct",
      "component": "brewer2026.coupled_kappa_t (extraction branch)",
      "label": "Extraction-only prediction",
      "method": "poroelastic closure driven by the 0-free-parameter dissolution Phi(t)",
      "role": "simulated",
      "unit": "g/s",
      "values": [
        0.0,
        0.0,
        0.0,
        0.0,
        0.0,
        0.0,
        0.0,
        0.0,
        0.0,
        0.0,
        0.0,
        0.00627,
        0.06169,
        0.14115,
        0.25908,
        0.42025,
        0.61583,
        0.82718,
        1.0215,
        1.2097,
        1.36978,
        1.49946,
        1.60077,
        1.67782,
        1.7353,
        1.77529,
        1.80668,
        1.82937,
        1.84569,
        1.85738,
        1.86573,
        1.87169,
        1.8757,
        1.87879,
        1.88098,
        1.88253,
        1.88364,
        1.88443,
        1.88498,
        1.88536,
        1.88564,
        1.88585,
        1.88599,
        1.8861,
        1.88617,
        1.88622,
        1.88626,
        1.88628,
        1.8863,
        1.88631,
        1.88632,
        1.88633,
        1.88634,
        1.88634,
        1.88634,
        1.88634,
        1.88634,
        1.88634,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635
      ]
    },
    {
      "caveat": "over-closes the shared porosity, so the opening driver floors and the prediction flattens at the wrong level — a diagnosed mis-scale, not a tuned fit",
      "component": "brewer2026.coupled_kappa_t (extraction+swelling)",
      "label": "Extraction + swelling composite",
      "method": "same shared-porosity state with the imported mo2023_2 swelling branch added",
      "role": "simulated",
      "unit": "g/s",
      "values": [
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635,
        1.88635
      ]
    },
    {
      "caveat": "deliberately simple; a more complex model that loses to this has not earned it",
      "component": "least-squares constant (1 free parameter)",
      "label": "Constant baseline",
      "method": "the window-optimal constant flow — the minimum a mechanism must beat",
      "role": "benchmark",
      "unit": "g/s",
      "values": [
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584,
        1.584
      ]
    },
    {
      "caveat": "extraction opens the pore space, tracking the rising flow",
      "component": "brewer2026.coupled_kappa_t (extraction branch)",
      "label": "Shared porosity — extraction only",
      "method": "eps(t) = eps0*(1 + Phi_extraction); opens above the eps0 reference",
      "role": "simulated",
      "unit": "porosity fraction (dimensionless)",
      "values": [
        0.17029,
        0.17041,
        0.17057,
        0.1708,
        0.17109,
        0.1715,
        0.17205,
        0.17278,
        0.17371,
        0.17487,
        0.17626,
        0.17775,
        0.17947,
        0.18124,
        0.18297,
        0.18455,
        0.18593,
        0.18708,
        0.18795,
        0.18868,
        0.18924,
        0.18965,
        0.18996,
        0.19018,
        0.19034,
        0.19045,
        0.19053,
        0.19059,
        0.19064,
        0.19067,
        0.19069,
        0.19071,
        0.19072,
        0.19072,
        0.19073,
        0.19073,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074,
        0.19074
      ]
    },
    {
      "caveat": "drops below the eps0 reference (over-closure) — the failure mechanism",
      "component": "brewer2026.coupled_kappa_t (extraction+swelling)",
      "label": "Shared porosity — composite",
      "method": "eps(t) = eps0*(1 + Phi_extraction + Phi_swelling), branches ADD as SIGNED relative porosity increments; Phi_swelling is <= 0, so the swelling branch closes the pore space",
      "role": "simulated",
      "unit": "porosity fraction (dimensionless)",
      "values": [
        0.16772,
        0.13417,
        0.12787,
        0.12343,
        0.12018,
        0.1174,
        0.1152,
        0.11348,
        0.11223,
        0.11142,
        0.11101,
        0.11095,
        0.11114,
        0.1115,
        0.1119,
        0.11226,
        0.1125,
        0.11258,
        0.11251,
        0.11229,
        0.11196,
        0.11154,
        0.11105,
        0.11054,
        0.11,
        0.10949,
        0.10895,
        0.10842,
        0.10791,
        0.10742,
        0.10694,
        0.10649,
        0.10609,
        0.10568,
        0.10529,
        0.10492,
        0.10457,
        0.10423,
        0.10392,
        0.10364,
        0.10335,
        0.10309,
        0.10283,
        0.10259,
        0.10237,
        0.10215,
        0.10196,
        0.10177,
        0.10159,
        0.10141,
        0.10125,
        0.1011,
        0.10095,
        0.10082,
        0.10069,
        0.10057,
        0.10045,
        0.10034,
        0.10023,
        0.10013,
        0.10005,
        0.09996,
        0.09987,
        0.09979
      ]
    }
  ],
  "source_commit": "7dd257e0b339f174c5da090a4a031e6e2c1b8a6a",
  "source_data_sha256": {
    "constants.csv": "0428390dae9c3032adb31d155dfc21b56ee34f0b407e8089fee3a31e47abf4ee",
    "solids_calibration.csv": "98cbdd42ea99dc454b7c150c86e07c78bca07e7987e5ac5a0f37b7008937e04d",
    "static_calibration.csv": "2a2fdd129cbfb7742196abb493409c76aab11e2bef9f74aafb3df996c6b21ce5",
    "traces_time_dependent.csv": "40e76f43e1584912b55afcc4f15c28b797bf3ac6c3c380765b408cddd33d9fe9"
  },
  "source_ids": {
    "observed_trace": "Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.18046315 (CC-BY-4.0)",
    "poroelastic_model": "waszkiewicz2025.poroelastic",
    "swelling_model": "mo2023_2.swelling (Elsevier 10.1016/j.jfoodeng.2023.111843, paywalled)",
    "synthesis": "brewer2026.coupled_kappa_t (docs/cards/brewer2026_coupled_kappa_t.md)"
  },
  "story_id": "PV-05",
  "time_axis_s": [
    0.0,
    1.6016,
    3.2032,
    4.8048,
    6.30631,
    7.90791,
    9.50951,
    11.11111,
    12.71271,
    14.31431,
    15.91592,
    17.41742,
    19.01902,
    20.62062,
    22.22222,
    23.82382,
    25.42543,
    27.02703,
    28.52853,
    30.13013,
    31.73173,
    33.33333,
    34.93494,
    36.53654,
    38.13814,
    39.63964,
    41.24124,
    42.84284,
    44.44444,
    46.04605,
    47.64765,
    49.24925,
    50.75075,
    52.35235,
    53.95395,
    55.55556,
    57.15716,
    58.75876,
    60.36036,
    61.86186,
    63.46346,
    65.06507,
    66.66667,
    68.26827,
    69.86987,
    71.47147,
    72.97297,
    74.57457,
    76.17618,
    77.77778,
    79.37938,
    80.98098,
    82.58258,
    84.08408,
    85.68569,
    87.28729,
    88.88889,
    90.49049,
    92.09209,
    93.69369,
    95.19519,
    96.7968,
    98.3984,
    100.0
  ],
  "title": "More Physics Made It Worse",
  "units": {
    "composite_clamped": "boolean",
    "composite_rmse_g_per_s": "g/s",
    "const_baseline_level_g_per_s": "g/s",
    "const_baseline_rmse_g_per_s": "g/s",
    "constant_free_params": "count",
    "degeneracy_agreement_g_per_s": "g/s",
    "eps0_reference_porosity": "porosity fraction (dimensionless)",
    "eval_window_end_s": "s",
    "eval_window_start_s": "s",
    "extraction_free_params": "count",
    "extraction_only_rmse_degeneracy_g_per_s": "g/s",
    "extraction_only_rmse_g_per_s": "g/s",
    "extraction_vs_constant_improvement": "ratio",
    "min_shared_porosity": "porosity fraction (dimensionless)",
    "n_window_points": "count",
    "rmse_ratio_composite_over_constant": "ratio",
    "rmse_ratio_composite_over_extraction": "ratio",
    "swelling_closes_shared_state": "boolean"
  },
  "values": {
    "composite_clamped": false,
    "composite_rmse_g_per_s": 0.648,
    "const_baseline_level_g_per_s": 1.584,
    "const_baseline_rmse_g_per_s": 0.573,
    "constant_free_params": 1,
    "degeneracy_agreement_g_per_s": 0.0,
    "eps0_reference_porosity": 0.17,
    "eval_window_end_s": 95.0,
    "eval_window_start_s": 15.0,
    "extraction_free_params": 0,
    "extraction_only_rmse_degeneracy_g_per_s": 0.116,
    "extraction_only_rmse_g_per_s": 0.116,
    "extraction_vs_constant_improvement": 4.94,
    "min_shared_porosity": 0.0998,
    "n_window_points": 800,
    "rmse_ratio_composite_over_constant": 1.131,
    "rmse_ratio_composite_over_extraction": 5.586,
    "swelling_closes_shared_state": true
  }
}
